I ordered the Revlon Colorstay makeup in Caramel and received a horrid color and the makeup was even separated which could be seen through the glass. The cap was soiled and cracked, as well. The seller refused to respond until I went through the eBay site, then when he did, he refused to acknowledge the product was defective. His resolution is a full refund of what I paid, but he refuses to pay for return shipping. He's dishonest and is trying to get away with this behavior because he's received such a high approval rating from most customers. Clearly not all, since he did not merit a 100% rating. The photo shows what I ordered, taken directly from his seller's page and what I normally order from other sellers, and the garbage he dared to send me.