Lexylicious Ice Cream Cafe in Columbus, New Jersey, is home to the best ice cream in New Jersey! Famous for our award-winning ice cream sandwiches, we’ve expanded our menu to offer even more delicious treats. Stop by our ice cream cafe for rich, handcrafted milkshakes, indulgent sundaes, and a full selection of premium ice cream flavors. Need a pick-me-up? We now serve fresh-brewed coffee and espresso to pair with your favorite sweet treat. Planning an event? We offer ice cream catering in NJ, including tea party catering, to make any celebration sweeter. Visit us in Columbus, NJ read full review »