I took my vehicle to CarMax for an appraisal to see what they would offer me for it. But before going, I did plenty of research to know the true value of the car, which was a 2003 model with only 52k miles and in outstanding condition both inside and outside: Kelley Blue Book Private Party Sale value = $10, 325 Kelley Blue Book Trade-In value = $8, 200 CarMax Offer: $6, 500! I then pulled out two current CarMax listings for similar vehicles (same year, make, and model -- although the two active CarMax listings were a lower... read full review »